Every time we hear about Chris Clark’s good health and fitness for beginning the season, we’re also sadly reminded that his injury was caused by bad ice at the home rink. And what’s worse, these deplorable ice conditions at Centre Verizón gave a competitive advantage to the Flyers, in the view of the opponents themselves, in last season’s first round playoff matchup.
It’s been radio silence all summer long as to whether any changes or improvements have been made since April. (Though, to these unrtained eyes, the sheet looked pretty good to me at Kettler.) At least publicly, no one within the organization seems willing to discuss the matter.
Over the weekend, I stumbled upon this detailed article from the “SI Vault,” written in 2004. Though dated, its worth your time if you’re at all interested in the subject. The piece discusses the ice conditions throughout the NHL, methods to improve the quality of the playing sheet, and the importance of it all.
Here’s a rather salient passage:
In 1997 the NHL hired [Dan Craig, the NHL's facilities operations manager], the [then] rink guru in Edmonton, to address leaguewide ice issues, and the NHL has since made a concerted effort to improve playing conditions. Among the corrective measures: [shortening the pre-game warm-up, shoveling ice during TV timeouts, limiting on-ice promotions, etc.] encouraging rink operators to take ice-making courses given by the Ontario Recreation Facilities Association and its USA Hockey affiliate, STAR. Currently eight certified ice technicians work in NHL arenas; another 24 are nearing certification.
The biggest success story may be the ice at GM Place. In 2000 [Bob] Hartley asked the ice technicians at NHL arenas with so-called good ice to have their flood water chemically analyzed. Hartley was looking for something that might toughen the almost pure water. With the information he collected and the help of a microbiologist, Hartley developed a powder that essentially adds impurities to the arena’s water. Since Hartley put his product on the market in February 2003, Rite-Ice, which is now used in four NHL arenas, has caused a sensation—and not only because a suspicious customs agent held up a shipment to [Anaheim] for a few days . . . At the start of 2001-02, GM Place ice ranked 23rd in the NHL ratings. Through 300 games this season, it was tied for third.
Old news, but I wonder, have any of the Verizon rink operators ever taken these STAR courses? Has this chemical analysis, and resulting powder additive process, been considered, implemented?
After all, “it’s the most basic element in hockey,” and its importance cannot be understated.

7 comments
Comments feed for this article
October 6, 2008 at 10:56 am
J.P.
Unrelated: Dan Craig is a hell of a Bond.
October 6, 2008 at 11:06 am
Chris
FWIW, I have been at all three pre-season games, and the Verizon Center was appreciably colder for Game 1 vs Carolina than it was for the other two games. I don’t know if that had to do with the crowd or with the preceding evening’s events or what, but it was definitely noticeable. Last night, the puck really seemed as though it wouldn’t stay flat in the third, and yet there were four goals scored. Go figure.
October 6, 2008 at 11:18 am
pepper
Thanks Chris. I haven’t been able to get down for any of those games, so its helpful to have your perspective, as a preview.
October 6, 2008 at 12:45 pm
dmg
That’s interesting about Hartley, but I can’t say I’m surprised. I’ve skated on the ice at Philips Arena and from skating on it you can tell it’s nothing close to pure water.
October 6, 2008 at 1:04 pm
J.P.
It’s worth noting that during the preseason so far, the VC hasn’t had a basketball game the night before a Caps game (though there was a New Kids concert, apparently, on Thursday night… we’ll have to ask Tarik how it was), and it has always in the past seemed that perhaps more than the weather outside (or inside) the quality of the ice is determined by how recently the event staff has had to break down the basketball court or whatever on top of the ice.
Point being, the ice is always better when the Wiz and Hoyas aren’t in season and the VC isn’t as busy.
October 6, 2008 at 2:08 pm
I Rock the Red
I thought it was pretty cold in the arena last night, but I wasn’t wearing my sweatshirt, so that may have something to do with it. From my perspective in section 429, there was a stripe of ice that didn’t seem to freeze solid until well after the Zamboni’s left.
I’ll be the first to admit I don’t know exactly how the Zamboni’s do what they do - and I’d love for someone to enlighten me! - but I do think having both of them enter and leave the arena via the same point may contribute to the “wet” look in front of the exit.
I did notice that they hand-patched one bad spot down by us during one of the breaks, and that was good; leaving it unrepaired would have been bad. It looked like it took a couple of handfulls of chips to straighten it out; that’s a pretty deep gash!
November 14, 2008 at 11:45 am
Keith
The Zam performs three tasks:
1. Shaves off some of the surface ice - the depth of the shave varies.
2. Rinses the ice surface with cold water which is sucked up, filtered, and re-used.
3. Spreads hot water behind the machine to smooth the surface and freeze into new ice.
Air is the biggest enemy of good ice. The hotter the water, the less air there is in it, but the more energy it takes to freeze ($$). The ice thickness in the edges and corners can be up to an inch greater than the ice thickness at the center and in the creases - at bad rinks, ice in the center usually freezes really quickly, but the corners and ends often stay wet (ice is an insulator). Some drivers drop extra water in the creases to compensate for wear-and-tear, which only makes things worse as the water doesn’t have time to freeze hard (less than 24 degrees fahrenheit). Ice that is too warm makes for slow skating; ice that is too cold is brittle, and tends to spall.
Ruts occur when big skaters turn quickly; a half-inch deep groove is typical, and those ruts can be almost impossible to fix between periods except by shaving deeply - which isn’t possible if the ice thickness is under a half-inch.
The keys to good ice?
1. Commitment to good ice on th epart of management!
2. Water treatment and additives.
2. Equipment maintenance.
4. Operator training.
5. Quality control and player feedback.